A fantastic television ad by Ally Bank, in my view best describes how Limited Partners (LPs) as the investors committed to Venture have been fooled.
In the event you have not seen the video, it shows a slick man in a business suit sitting cosily around a kids table with two little girls.
The suit then asks one girl if she would want a pony. When she replies yes, he hands her a toy pony. He then moves on to the second girl and asks her if she wants a pony, and then calls in a real pony. Clearly the first girl is upset that she did not get a real pony and complains, upon which the man replies, “well, you didn’t ask.”
What pony did you ask for, by virtue of your actions?
That is exactly what has happened to LPs in Venture who did not ask the specific questions that could have led to their success in Venture. In many cases those LPs failed to generate impressive returns in Venture because they did not know they had to ask specific questions and should have taken control of the situation in order to get the results that the sector is able to generate.
Many LPs, glowing at the early return profiles of Bill Draper, Vinod Khosla and other early luminaries, simply said “yes” to General Partners (GPs) who asked LPs if they wanted Venture returns, without even asking how much (see the many PPM’s that do not even have clear return targets).
And of course now, many LPs are utterly disappointed and mistrust the GPs (and worse the sector), similar to how the little girl in the video now mistrusts the man.
Ask the right questions
To help make clear to LPs what questions to ask I have added a new section to the wildly popular presentation The State of Venture Capital, the Prelude (posted originally on Slideshare) describing how an LP thought his commitment would be applied, and how it was in reality.
We pride ourselves on a solid and no-nonsense understanding of the Venture ecosystem, top-to-bottom, which is crucial in leading to a permanent fix in Venture and to improve its performance. So, we back up our rational on the right side of the previous slide with the observations of how the Venture business really operates today.
The bottom line is simple. It is okay to deploy your money as an LP through GPs as the arbiter, but just like many Hollywood stars have found out, if you are not signing your own checks, know what they are being spent on and how – don’t be surprised your money will be taken for a ride. It is the nature of letting go of financial control (and really, you should not be surprised).
Today’s Venture pipes are still being pumped full with subprime deals, which means the ten-year outlook for Venture will not look much different from its miserable ten-year past. So, the time to act is now if you expect a different outcome in ten years.
The Venture business needs to be reigned in, with controls put in place so it can no longer be taken for a ride.
The sector has a bright future ahead, with massive market-pull from the majority of people in this world who still crave technology solutions to improve their lives. The only way we, as the most innovative nation in the world can screw it up is to deploy a piece-meal financial system that misses its intended target.
That has to stop, right now.
Dear LP, a permanent fix to Venture, by way of a new economic system you can deploy, is waiting for you. Act now or forever hold your peace.
- Capitalism without the deployment of operating principles that secure a meritocracy is an oligarchic system in violation of the most rudimentary definition of freedom we owe ourselves. — Georges van Hoegaerden - February 1, 2015
- Equality is a fantasy of extraordinary proportion. — Georges van Hoegaerden - January 21, 2015
- If no man is created equal, why then do we debate equal pay? — Georges van Hoegaerden - January 21, 2015
- CalPERS pre-empts asset allocation - January 21, 2015
- Homogenization of people is a bad idea, we ought to focus on the value of our differences, not on the rut of our commonalities. — Georges van Hoegaerden - January 14, 2015
- Only realism can breed justifiable optimism. — Georges van Hoegaerden - January 14, 2015
- The fix to improving asset management’s effectiveness lies in its reinvention, not in the optimization of its bloated past. — Georges van Hoegaerden - January 13, 2015
- How to fix Twitter - January 8, 2015
- CalPERS change, a new schtick or a new stick? - December 28, 2014
- The risk profile – not money – determines what innovation can be discovered. — Georges van Hoegaerden - September 16, 2014